Grocery shopping guides, supermarket price comparisons & tips - Vlog /food-and-drink/groceries You deserve better, safer and fairer products and services. We're the people working to make that happen. Sun, 14 Dec 2025 22:23:53 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 /wp-content/uploads/2024/12/favicon.png?w=32 Grocery shopping guides, supermarket price comparisons & tips - Vlog /food-and-drink/groceries 32 32 239272795 Jatz, Savoy, Ritz or Aldi Eton: Which cracker tastes best? /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/jatz-savoy-ritz-or-aldi-eton-which-cracker-tastes-best Sun, 14 Dec 2025 22:21:52 +0000 /?p=844744 Who is the king of the crackers? We conducted a blind taste test to find out

The post Jatz, Savoy, Ritz or Aldi Eton: Which cracker tastes best? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
While the cracker aisle of the supermarket is awash with options, for many, the plain round cracker is the classic choice any time you’re entertaining. 

But with many similar options available, how do you know which one is really the best accompaniment to your cheese and dips? 

Text-only accessible version

Which classic cracker tastes best?

We conducted a blind taste test of the similar Jatz, Savoy, Ritz and Aldi Eton to find out which one tastes best.

Top scoring
Aldi Damora Eton crackers, Made in Australia, 225g box. $1.49

Second place
Mondelez Ritz, Made in Indonesia, 227g box. $3.50

Third place
Arnott’s Savoy, Made in Australia, 225g box. $4

Fourth place
Arnott’s Jatz, Made in Australia, 225g box. $4

Selection and voting

Water crackers, rice crackers and crackers featuring cheese, seeds, fruit and other flavourings are widely available at our supermarkets, but there’s something to be said for a plain cracker as the perfect vehicle for whatever topping you want to serve up to your guests.

To compare the similar options available at our supermarkets, we asked our tasters to sample Arnott’s Jatz and Savoy, Mondelez’s Ritz and Aldi’s home-brand Eton cracker. 

All four are round, approximately 45mm in diameter, with the classic serrated edge and evenly spaced holes in the centre. 

Vlog staff were asked to blind taste-test each option, cleansing their palates with water between each sample. After trying all four, they cast a single vote for their favourite variety.

A taster casts their vote for their favourite cracker.
A staff member casts their vote.

And the winner is

In a clear victory, Aldi’s Eton beat out the competition, earning a whopping 48% of the vote. Ritz came second with 22%, followed by Savoy with 19% while Jatz scored last place with just 11% of tasters nominating it as their favourite.

The Aldi Eton cracker is also a winner on price. A 225g box costs just $1.49 compared to the $4 you’ll pay for the same-sized box of Jatz or Savoy. Ritz crackers are $3.50 for a 227g box.

In judging the options, more than one taster noted that the Savoy was more salty than the other options, which was a plus for some, though others found its saltiness was overpowering. 

The Ritz was described as too soft and crumbly, and one taster said it was better on its own, rather than as an accompaniment to cheese or dips. Jatz was described as having a nice, hard crunch, but the Eton was said to be “just right”.

Jatz, Ritz, Savoy and Eton crackers side-by-side.
These four similar-looking crackers have some subtle differences.

What’s in your cracker?

While the listed ingredients in all of these crackers are similar, there are some notable differences. 

Ritz are made with fructose syrup, the Savoy uses golden syrup, and both Eton and Jatz use malt extract from barley. 

All options contain sugar, salt and baking powder. Eton, Jatz and Savoy crackers carry a two-star health rating, but the Ritz crackers don’t provide a rating.

Other ingredients you might find in these crackers include:

  • herb extract and yeast (Jatz, Eton and Savoy)
  • emulsifiers (Jatz, Savoy and Ritz)
  • acidity regulators (Eton)
  • food acid (Jatz)
  • enzymes (Ritz).

The Ritz also contains added minerals (iron and zinc) as well as vitamins (riboflavin, thiamin and folate).

As some of our tasters noted, one cracker is much saltier than the others. The Savoy contains 848mg of sodium per 100g compared to 490mg, 497mg and 427mg per 100g in the Jatz, Eton and Ritz crackers, respectively. The Ritz cracker is the only one of the four not made in Australia, being manufactured in Indonesia.

Are Jatz and Savoy the same? 

While Arnott’s make both of these very similar crackers, they are not exactly the same. 

Savoy crackers were originally made by Melbourne baker, the Brockhoff Biscuit Company. When Arnott’s merged with this firm in the 1960s, they responded to Victorian consumers who wanted to keep their preferred variety and continued to make the Savoy.

The difference between the two crackers is minor. Apart from the difference in sodium (see ‘What’s in your cracker’, above), the ingredient lists reveal that while Jatz are made with malt extract from barley, the Savoy is made with golden syrup.

The packaging is also very similar, as are the crackers themselves, though look closely and you’ll see the word ‘Savoy’ stamped onto one side of that variety. 

In terms of availability, you’ll mostly find the Savoy in Victoria and Tasmania, though it can be found in some independent retailers in other states. Jatz is available around the country.

The post Jatz, Savoy, Ritz or Aldi Eton: Which cracker tastes best? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
844744 a staff member enters their vote for their favourite cracker boxes of the four crackers side by side
How to make the most of your leftover Christmas ham /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/how-to-make-the-most-of-your-leftover-christmas-ham Fri, 12 Dec 2025 01:57:04 +0000 /?p=861967 Extend the ham love beyond Christmas with these delicious tips.

The post How to make the most of your leftover Christmas ham appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
Every year, Vlog puts in the hard yards to figure out which ham deserves a place at your Christmas table. But what actually happens to all the leftover hams once our testing is done? I’m happy to report that not a single ham goes to waste.

Vlog is a wonderful place to work for many reasons, but on some days it feels extra special. The day you see a message pop up on your screen informing you that “leftover Christmas ham is in the kitchen”, is one of those days.

Cut to me, last December, elbowing colleagues out of the way to secure a top rated ham, driving home with 5kg of ham strapped into the passenger seat (it triggered the seat belt alarm), wondering what on earth to do with it all. If you’ve ever found yourself wondering the same thing post Christmas lunch, with a huge ham sitting on your bench, you’re not alone.

I’m here to share my tips and tricks for putting every last morsel to good use.

Gift it 

You can (and should) continue to spread the joy of ham with friends and family well beyond the 25th of December. Who doesn’t love getting to take leftovers home from a Christmas lunch? It’s arguably one of the best gifts you can receive during the festive season. 

I have fond memories of sitting in the back of the car on the drive home to Sydney after Christmas with my grandparents, my brother and I trying to quietly crack open a takeaway container of ham without alerting our parents in the front seat. These days, I continue the tradition by ensuring every friend and family member leaves my house with a container of ham. 

A word of caution to would-be ham recipients: wait to be offered said ham by your host, never assume leftovers are yours for the taking.

Next-day leftovers 

Ham is a great addition to many classic recipes that can be enjoyed in the weeks after Christmas –  soups, baked pasta, quiche, potato salad, scrambled eggs and omelets can all benefit from a healthy helping of diced ham. I have also found that it’s delicious in fried rice. 

Not a fan of dicing? You can go one step simpler and crumb thick sliced ham to make schnitzels or a cheese and ham toastie.

Freeze it 

Now, for my top tip – freeze your ham. But crucially, before you do, it’s best to dice it up and freeze it in thin layers so you can easily add it to your dish. 

Frozen ham can last up to 6 months in your freezer. Just wrap it up well to avoid freezer burn and make sure to use it all up once you’ve defrosted it (never defrost and re-freeze).

Extend the life of your ham by storing it correctly and using it in a variety of delicious recipes.

Make stock 

The ham bone is an often-overlooked part of the ham, but it is absolutely packed with flavour and minerals. You can pop it straight into a pot, let it simmer for a few hours and freeze the stock for later.

Or, if you’re feeling particularly lazy after a big festive lunch, just freeze the whole bone and make stock for soup later on. Either way, you’ll be grateful in 6 months time when you can relive a little taste of Christmas in the cold winter months.

Get even

If the worst happens and you forget about your ham, returning to your fridge weeks later to find it has gone bad, fear not – there is one final way to put it to use. A friend of mine (who will remain anonymous) once shared a story from his childhood about an ongoing feud with a neighbour.

After Christmas one year, his mum decided she’d had enough. She grabbed their rotting ham, ran across the road, and hid it in his hedge. We do not, for the record, recommend this last option for legal reasons.

Happy hamming.

The post How to make the most of your leftover Christmas ham appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
861967 person carving christmas ham on chopping board Extend the life of your ham by storing it correctly and using it in a variety of delicious recipes.
Are these products being hit by skimpflation? /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/skimpflation Mon, 08 Dec 2025 04:19:00 +0000 /?p=856603 Ingredient changes have left some consumers with a skimping feeling. Companies say the changes are for our own good.

The post Are these products being hit by skimpflation? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>

Need to know

  • Skimpflation is when a product’s main ingredients are reduced in favour of cheaper alternatives, but the price stays the same
  • Following shrinkflation, it’s the latest subtle measure manufacturers are accused of introducing to save money
  • Some consumers say they’re seeing it with their favourite items, but manufacturers say the changes are for our benefit

Regular Vlog readers will be familiar with shrinkflation – where a product gets smaller, but stays the same price or becomes more expensive.

Our investigations over the years have revealed how it’s being applied to everything from breakfast cereals and pet foods to Easter chocolates and Christmas treats.

But now a more subtle phenomenon is rearing its head.

‘Skimpflation’ is when, instead of making less of a product in order to save money, manufacturers change what they make the product with to achieve the same objective.

Skimpflating businesses will reduce expensive ingredients or components in favour of cheaper ones to produce a product that is the same size and retails for the same price, but is cheaper to make.

This shift to cheaper ingredients can affect the item’s nutritional value, resulting in an inferior or less healthy product

In the case of food, this shift to cheaper ingredients can affect the item’s nutritional value, resulting in an inferior or less healthy product.

In October this year, , revealing almost 50 products whose main or characterising ingredients appeared to have been reduced.

Vlog supporters get involved

Skimpflation is hard to spot, but the prospect of paying the same for an inferior product has motivated Vlog members and supporters to share their own examples of products they suspect have undergone skimpflation.

Consumers have come forward with granolas, yoghurts and toothpastes that have stayed the same price, but changed their ingredients.

Buyers of some of these items have expressed frustration that manufacturers changed their favourite products without informing them, leaving them paying the same price for products they say aren’t as good as they used to be.

Cereal offender

Aldi’s Goldenvale granola (left) appears to have been replaced with a new, less healthy variety (right). Image: Aldi

One product brought to our attention is a honey pecan granola sold by Aldi.

As recently as July this year, the supermarket was selling this version of the popular breakfast snack under its Goldenvale brand for $6.99 in 300g packets.

According to Aldi’s website, that specific product is no longer available.

It appears to have been replaced with another granola, which comes in almost identical packaging, in the same size and for the same price, but branded under Hillcrest, another of Aldi’s many home-brand labels.

These cosmetic alterations mask some significant ingredient changes.

The product has gone from having seeds as its main ingredient to dried coconut. The Hillcrest version still claims to be “seeds galore,” despite being only 33% seeds compared to Goldenvale’s 52%.

This honey pecan granola has also recorded a small drop in how much honey and pecan nuts it contains.

Capping off these changes, the product has also dropped one and a half stars from its health rating and ended up with a lower proportion of Australian ingredients.

The Hillcrest version isn’t impressing some Aldi shoppers, with several taking to Aldi groups on Facebook to complain the product tastes worse than the Goldenvale variety.

Rebranded yoghurt

Before and after: Jalna recently changed the type of milk in these yoghurt pouches and stopped claiming they were organic. Image: Jalna

Another food item whose ingredient changes haven’t been missed by eagle-eyed shoppers and influencers on social media is Jalna’s line of kids yoghurt pouches.

In April this year, Jalna was making these strawberry, vanilla and blueberry flavoured products with full-cream milk and each carried a prominent “Organic” certification.

Six months later, the pouches were still the same size and retailing for the same price at major supermarkets, but had swapped full-cream milk for skim.

Jalna also no longer describes the products as organic, swapping the claim for an “All natural” promise.

Changing toothpastes

It’s not just foods whose changing inputs are being picked up on by consumers.

One longtime Oral B customer says some of the brand’s toothpastes taste worse following changes to ingredients and manufacturing.

One longtime user of Oral B products recently drew our attention to a range of alterations to the ingredients of two types of toothpaste.

A close look at the back of tubes of the Gum & Enamel Protect Daily Protection and Complete Defence System Deep Clean varieties reveals parent company Procter & Gamble recently shifted production of these products from Germany to China.

Information provided there also shows the new Chinese-made versions of the products have fewer and different ingredients than those made in Germany.

The new toothpastes still come in 110g tubes, but have recently attracted negative feedback in online reviews.

The longtime user who contacted us about the products said their prices have stayed the same, but argued the new versions were “lower quality”, with the new ingredients leading to unwanted changes in taste and texture.

Why are these products changing?

In response to questions from Vlog, the manufacturers of these products said they had changed their ingredients for the benefit of customers.

Aldi said it will return its Goldenvale granola to stores following questions from Vlog.

Aldi said it tries to bring shoppers “new and exciting flavours” and introduced the Hillcrest granola to “see what customers think”.

The company also told us the original Goldenvale granola will be back in its stores next year.

Jalna parent company Lactalis Australia said it switched to skim milk to better control the fat content of its yoghurt pouches. It said it dropped the organic certification of these products because, while some shoppers valued it, “for many it wasn’t a key factor in them choosing Jalna yoghurt.”

Neither did Procter & Gamble miss an opportunity to trumpet its services to consumers.

It said “the core motivation” of the changes to its toothpastes was “product performance and consumer benefit”, in particular to improve “foaming [and] brushing experience”.

Are they doing it to save money?

Manufacturers have often cited cost pressures when asked to explain other subtle product changes, such as shrinkflation.

After all, the costs of manufacturing inputs have seen some big increases in recent years, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

In September, agricultural lender Rabobank warned some food producers were using skimpflation along with shrinkflation to protect profit margins without losing consumers.

The bank said this is especially the case for makers of foods with ingredients whose prices have been volatile (such as chocolate), and that these manufacturers are embedding shrinkage and skimping into their long-term strategies.

The manufacturers we spoke to for this article either denied product changes were made to save money or declined to comment, but Aldi did say that it always considers cost when developing a new product.

Experts weigh in

Do the reasons manufacturers gave us for these product changes add up?

In the case of Oral B’s toothpaste, Associate Professor and dental health expert at Melbourne University Matt Hopcraft backed up Procter & Gamble’s explanation.

Following a review of the ingredient changes of both products, he said he suspected they were made based on customer feedback and to improve the user experience.

The changes to Aldi’s granola, however, drew the concern of Damian Maganja from the Food Policy Division of the George Institute for Global Health. Noting how the newer Hillcrest variety had double the saturated fat due to the influx of coconut and more sugars, he’s concerned longtime purchasers of the Goldenvale product could now be getting a worse-quality product without realising.

If it’s a product you’re buying all the time, you’re probably not going to be checking the nutritional information

Damian Maganja, George Institute for Global Health

“The products look almost exactly identical in every way. If it’s a product you’re buying all the time, you’re probably not going to be checking the nutritional information … people are going to be getting this extra whack of unhealthy nutrients,” he says.

Maganja says he isn’t sure whether Aldi’s changes make the product cheaper to produce, but says Jalna may have saved some money by no longer certifying its yogurt pouches as organic.

Ingredient changes the latest subtle strategy

Vlog is keen to hear of any instances of suspected skimpflation. 

“Consumers are bombarded by a range of tricks and traps at the supermarket that make it hard to get the best value for money,” says Andy Kelly, director of campaigns and communications at Vlog. 

“Skimpflation can lead consumers to unknowingly pay more for a worse-quality product and it can be even more difficult to detect than other tricks, like shrinking the size of the product while keeping the price the same.”

Skimpflation can lead consumers to unknowingly pay more for a worse-quality product

Andy Kelly, director of campaigns and communications at Vlog

The government has recently been considering how to make grocery retailers display notices when a product has shrunk in size or volume, but stayed the same price. Kelly says this is a good idea, but is concerned manufacturers may be switching from this tactic – shrinkflating – to skimpflating their products instead, in order to preserve profit margins.

“The rules need to be designed to prevent companies gaming the system,” he says. “They shouldn’t be allowed to avoid detection by artificially decreasing, inflating or delaying price increases when a product reduces in size, or by slightly altering the ingredients or the name of the product to avoid detection.”

You can share examples of skimpflation with us by contacting campaigns@choice.com.au or the author.

The post Are these products being hit by skimpflation? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
856603 aldi goldenvale paleo and aldi hillcrest paleo honey pecan granola jalna kids organic and jalna kids yoghurt vanilla flavoured old and new tubes of oral b gum and enamel protect daily protection aldi logo
The best tinned tomatoes in our taste test /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/the-best-tinned-tomatoes-in-our-taste-test Wed, 12 Nov 2025 13:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/the-best-tinned-tomatoes-in-our-taste-test/ We sampled 18 diced or chopped tomatoes from leading brands to find which tasted best.

The post The best tinned tomatoes in our taste test appeared first on Vlog.

]]>

Need to know

  • The best tasting tinned tomato in our test – Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic – was also the most expensive
  • Three supermarket brand products (two from Coles and one from Community Co) were the other products to earn a recommendation
  • Woolworths Australian Diced Tomatoes was the best product made from Australian tomatoes

On this page:

Tinned tomatoes are a pantry staple that most home cooks will reach for at least once a week.

But with so many options at our supermarkets, it can be tricky to choose the right one. Are Australian- or Italian-grown tomatoes best? Is it worth paying more for organic varieties? Are budget options just as good as more expensive products?

To help make the decision a little easier, we conducted a blind taste test of 18 diced or chopped tomatoes to find out which tastes best.

Text-only accessible version

Which tinned tomatoes taste best?

We sampled 18 diced or chopped tomatoes from leading brands in a blind taste test to find which tasted best.

1st place

Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic ($2.95) – 80%

2nd place

Coles Cucina Matese Diced Tomatoes ($1.40) – 75%

3rd place

Coles Italian Diced Tomatoes ($1.10) and Community Co Italian Diced Tomatoes ($1.30) – 75%

Best Australian

Woolworths Australian Diced Tomatoes ($1.30) – 73%

Highest sodium

Mutti Polpa Finely Chopped Tomatoes ($2.30) – 69%
120mg/100g sodium

Most additives

Coles Australian Diced Tomatoes ($1.30) – 67%
(Tomato puree, acidity regulator and firming agent)

Lowest scoring

Black & Gold Chopped Tomatoes ($0.95) – 48%

Cheapest

Aldi Remano Italian Diced Tomatoes (48%) and Black & Gold Chopped Tomatoes (58%) – $0.95

Most expensive

Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic ($2.95) – 80%

Top tinned tomatoes in our test

Of the 18 chopped or diced tinned tomatoes included in our blind taste test, four received a Vlog Expert Rating of 75% or more, earning them recommended status.

Supermarket brands gave a good showing, with two of the recommended products coming from Coles (one a home brand, one from Coles phantom brand, Cucina Matese) and one from IGA’s Community Co brand. Mutti Polpa Organic – the most expensive product in our test – took the top spot.

The Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic product earned the highest rating in our test, with a score of 80%.

Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic

Vlog Expert Rating: 80%

Price per 400g tin: $2.95

Experts say: “Rich red colour, chunky texture, thick juice. Pleasant flavour. Good consistency.” “Thick sauce, luxe texture, rich, vibrant, tomatoey flavour and beautifully balanced.”

The Coles Cucina Matese Diced Tomatoes was the second highest scoring product, earning a Vlog Expert Rating of 76%.

Coles Cucina Matese Diced Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 76%

Price per 400g tin: $1.40

Experts say: “Pleasant tomato aroma.” “Balanced sweet and acidic taste.” “Good, smooth consistency. Well-rounded, balanced flavour.”

Equal third were two supermarket brand products: Community Co Italian Diced Tomatoes and Coles Italian Diced Tomatoes.

Coles Italian Diced Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 75%

Price per 400g tin: $1.10

Experts say: “Pleasant appearance, nice, juicy consistency.” “Fresh, tomatoey aroma.” “Perfect for soups and chunky pasta sauces.”

Community Co Italian Diced Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 75%

Price per 400g tin: $1.30

Experts say: “Bright red colour, fresh tomatoey smell.” “More saucy/liquidy (so perhaps better for soups, pasta sauces). Clean, fresh, tomatoey flavour.”

Cheapest tomatoes in our test

Our tests often show that price is not always an indicator of performance and that’s the case here. While the most expensive product in our test came out on top, some of the least expensive earned good scores.

For example, the Coles Italian Diced Tomatoes was equal third-cheapest, but ranked joint third and were recommended.

But unfortunately, there were also a lot of cheap products that underwhelmed our testers – including the three cheapest in our test (excluding the Coles product mentioned above which costs the same as the Woolworths product in this list).

Aldi Remano Italian Diced Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 58%

Price per 400g tin: $0.95

Experts say: “A bit watery, slightly bitter and acidic.” “Slightly metallic, with limited flavour.” “Pale colour, thin juice, slightly sour/bitter taste.”

Black & Gold Chopped Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 48%

Price per 400g tin: $0.95

Experts say: “Very watery with a mild aroma.” “Bitter, sour flavour.” “Lots of discoloured green/yellow pieces.”

Woolworths Diced Italian Tomatoes

Vlog Expert Rating: 63%

Price per 400g tin: $1.10

Experts say: “Flavour sour and bitter.” “Lots of green, large chunks.” Limited tomato flavour and tomatoes taste under-ripe.” Very acidic and bitter taste.”

Most expensive tinned tomatoes in our test

While the most expensive product in our test came out on top, some of the other pricier varieties didn’t score so well and were beaten by much more budget-friendly brands.

  • Mutti Polpa Finely Chopped Tomatoes – $2.30 per 400g tin; Vlog Expert Rating: 69%
  • Val Verde Diced Italian Tomatoes – $2.90 per 400g tin; 68%
  • Coles Certified Organic Italian Diced Tomatoes –$1.70 per 400g tin; 64%
  • Woolworths Macro Wholefoods Market Organic Diced Tomatoes – $1.70 per 400g tin; 73%
  • Aldi Remano Italian Diced Tomatoes Organic – $1.59 per 400g tin; 65%
The highest scoring Australian product in our test was the Woolworths Australian Diced Tomatoes, which earned a score of 73%,

Best Australian varieties

While 13 of the 18 samples we tested were produced in Italy, the largest global exporter of canned tomatoes, we also included five locally produced varieties in our test.

Woolworths Australian Diced Tomatoes ($1.30 per 400g tin) was the best of the bunch, with a score of 73%. Leggo’s Australian Diced Tomatoes ($1.80) was fairly close behind with a score of 71%.

The Coles ($1.30) and Ardmona ($2.10) Australian Diced Tomatoes both earned 67%.

Aldi’s Remano Australian Diced Tomatoes were the cheapest of the Australian products at $1.19 per 400g tin, but earned just 54% in our taste test.

Organic options

If you prefer to buy organic, you’re in luck: it was an organic product – the Mutti Polpa Chopped Tomatoes Organic – that took out the top spot in our taste test.

We also tested organic varieties from Coles, Woolworths and Aldi. The Coles and Aldi organic products failed to impress, but the Woolworths Macro Wholefoods Market Organic Diced Italian Tomatoes ($1.70) received a score of 73% – falling just short of the recommended mark.

Additives in tinned tomatoes

Diced tomatoes and juice were the most common ingredients in the products we sampled. Six products contained nothing else, while the Mutti Polpa Finely Chopped Tomatoes contained only tomatoes and no juice, though it did contain salt. Leggo’s Australian Diced Tomatoes was the only other product containing added salt.

Acidity regulators

Nine of the products contained citric acid or another unspecified acidity regulator. Acidity regulators are added to tinned tomatoes to lower pH levels, helping to preserve the product and extend shelf life. They can also be used to balance flavour and help stop the natural red colour of the tomatoes from fading to brown.

Firming agent

A firming agent – calcium chloride – was added to three products: Coles Australian Diced Tomatoes, Aldi Remano Australian Diced Tomatoes and Woolworths Australian Diced Tomatoes.

Firming agents help products retain their shape and texture to stop them from becoming mushy during the canning process. Calcium chloride also helps to retain pH levels, extend shelf life and reduce bacterial activity.

How we test tinned tomatoes

Products

We included products labelled as tinned or chopped tomatoes, excluding crushed and whole options. We chose products that are available nationally through at least one major supermarket chain.

Tasting

Our experts tasted the samples blind (without knowing the brands) in a randomised order and rated the tomatoes on taste, texture, aroma and appearance.

Scores

The ratings each product received were based on the scores for each aspect of the judging. The results were weighted as follows:

Flavour: 40%Texture: 20%Appearance: 20%Aroma: 20%

We recommend products with a rating of 75% or more.

Our expert taste testers (L to R): Jane Bardell, Pru Engel, Chantelle Dart and Fiona Mair.

Our expert testers

Fiona Mair is part of our Vlog kitchen lab team and has a degree in home economics and dietary supervision. She also conducts and judges food taste tests and is a judge for the Sydney Royal Fine Food Show.

Jane Bardell produces content for our Vlog insurance team, but also knows a thing or two about food, being an avid cook and baker. She holds a statement of attainment in sensory analyses for fine food judging.

Chantelle Dart is another member of our Vlog kitchen lab team whose expertise extends beyond her knowledge of our real-world cooking tests, having studied food technology, hospitality, business administration and event management.

Pru Engel is the Vlog audience and engagement editor and has enjoyed a long career working on some of Australia’s leading food magazines, where she honed her expertise in identifying quality ingredients and cooking with them.

The post The best tinned tomatoes in our taste test appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
767978 mutti-polpa-chopped-organic-tomatoes cucina-matese-italian-diced-tomatoes-1 tins-of-coles-italian-diced-tomatoes-and-community-co-italian-diced-tomatoes woolworths-australian-diced-tomatoes four-taste-testers
Coles, Woolworths, Aldi and IGA home brands in fruit pastry bake-off /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/home-brand-fruit-pastry-head-to-head Wed, 24 Sep 2025 14:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/home-brand-fruit-pastry-head-to-head/ We baked – and taste-tested – fruit pastries using home-brand ingredients to see which supermarket had the best.

The post Coles, Woolworths, Aldi and IGA home brands in fruit pastry bake-off appeared first on Vlog.

]]>

Need to know

  • The pastries made using Woolworths ingredients earned the most votes in our bake-off, followed by Coles, then Aldi and IGA
  • Products that appear very similar can perform quite differently
  • The ingredients from Coles and Woolworths were all priced identically

On this page:

One of our challenges in surveying supermarket prices each quarter is selecting truly comparable products from each of the stores we shop at. After all, subtle variations between similarly named grocery items can affect the way they taste and perform.

We consider ingredient lists, country of origin, pack sizes and a range of other factors when deciding what to include, but inconsistencies inevitably remain.

Are you getting good value if you spend less, but the outcome is disappointing?

As we often find in our appliance testing, price is not necessarily an indicator of performance, and it’s the same when it comes to food. Sometimes spending more means a better result, but sometimes the cheaper product will be better.

In our most recent quarterly basket survey, we created a list of home-brand products from each of the four major supermarkets to find out which cost less. But it raised the question: are you getting good value if you spend less but the outcome is disappointing?

So, we decided to put some of those home-brand products to the test.

Text-only accessible version

Woolworths, IGA, Coles and Aldi home brands compared

We used puff pastry, cream cheese and frozen berries from each of the supermarket home brands to create a baked treat and conducted a blind taste test to determine which brand’s products performed best.

Woolworths 1st place

Puff pastry $3.80 (highest sodium)

Frozen mixed berries $5.70 (packed in Chile)

Cream cheese $2.60 (highest total sugar)

Coles 2nd place

Puff pastry $3.80 (highest total sugar)

Frozen mixed berries $5.70 (packed in Serbia)

Cream cheese $2.60 (lowest kJ)

Aldi 3rd place

Puff pastry $3.79 (lowest sugar)

Frozen mixed berries $5.19 (packed in Chile)

Cream cheese $2.39 (highest sodium)

IGA 4th place

Puff pastry $3.80 (lowest total fat)

Frozen mixed berries $5.19 (packed in Serbia)

Cream cheese $2.39 (highest total fat)

We baked pastries using products from each of the four supermarket home brands.

The best tasting pastries

Vlog home economist Fiona Mair created pastries using home-brand frozen berries, cream cheese and puff pastry from Aldi, Coles, IGA and Woolworths. We then asked 31 Vlog staff to take part in a blind taste test to determine which supermarket’s home brand products delivered the best outcome.

Each taster tried a sample of the pastries made using home-brand ingredients from each of the supermarkets, then voted for the one they liked best. The winner, by a landslide, was Woolworths.

The winner, by a landslide, was Woolworths

This result was no surprise to Fiona, who assessed each ingredient while preparing the samples. She noted that the Woolworths pastry puffed up more than the other brands we tested. In contrast, she described the Black & Gold puff pastry from IGA as having a “greasy mouthfeel that coats the roof of the mouth”.

In our blind tasting, the IGA sample received only two votes, compared to the Woolworths sample, which earned 20 votes. The offerings from Aldi and Coles also failed to impress, earning just four and five votes respectively.

Frozen mixed berry comparisons

Each of the frozen mixed berry varieties varied slightly in composition.

Unlike the other brands, Woolworths does not provide the percentage of ingredients for each berry variety, instead listing blueberries, strawberries, blackberries and raspberries in that order.

Aldi’s Orchard & Vine frozen mixed berries states ingredients comprising 34% strawberries, 30% blueberries, 21% blackberries and 15% raspberries.

Community Co frozen mixed berries from IGA are slightly different: 35% blackberries, 25% strawberries, 20% blueberries and 20% raspberries.

The Coles mixed berries claim 37% blueberries, 33% strawberries, 15% blackberries and 15% raspberries.

There was very little correlation between the stated percentages of each type of berry and the actual quantities we recorded

Did they meet these claims? In the single samples we assessed, there was very little correlation between the stated percentages of each type of berry and the actual quantities we recorded.

  • Only Coles came close to matching the claimed percentages for two of the berries (strawberries and raspberries).
  • Community & Co matched its claims for blackberries.
  • Aldi was within 2% of the claim for the raspberries in its pack.
  • Aldi and Coles had more blackberries than claimed.
  • IGA had more strawberries at the expense of blueberries.

It should be noted that we only assessed one bag from each brand, so this is a simple snapshot. We would also expect to see some seasonal variation.

When assessing the products during the preparation of our pastries, Fiona found all packs contained some broken and squashed fruit, mostly the raspberries. The Coles product was the only one that contained sliced strawberries – all the others had whole fruit. She described the berries in each brand’s sample as sweet, with the caveat that the strawberries were a little sour.

Our test kitchen staff prepared the ingredients from each of the four supermarkets.

Cream cheese comparison

As would be expected, all of the cream cheese products had similar ingredients, but once again, Fiona’s assessment found some noticeable differences.

“The Aldi Westacre cream cheese was white, soft and creamy with a pleasant mouthfeel,” she says.

On the other hand, Fiona found the IGA Black & Gold cream cheese to be very thick, difficult to blend and slightly yellowish in colour.

“I could stand a spoon up in it – the texture was very stiff. It had an unpleasant mouthfeel, which left an unpleasant coating, and it wasn’t spreadable.”

She noted that the Woolworths and Coles products showed slight separation.

“The Coles cream cheese had a thick, creamy consistency but was slightly gluggy on the palate,” says Fiona.

“The Woolworths cream cheese had a slightly more sour taste but a creamy, soft texture with a pleasant mouthfeel.”

Text-only accessible version

Home brand puff pastry, frozen berries and cream cheese compared

Puff pastry

Elmsbury Puff Pastry Ready Rolled Sheets

Cost: $3.79

Energy: 1280kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 12.8g per 100g

Total Sugars: 0.7g per 100g

Sodium: 362mg per 100g

Coles Puff Pastry

Cost: $3.80

Energy: 1370kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 15g per 100g

Total Sugars: 1.5g per 100g

Sodium: 340mg per 100g

Black & Gold Australian Puff Pastry

Cost: $3.80

Energy: 1271kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 12.6g per 100g

Total Sugars: 1g per 100g

Sodium: 367mg per 100g

Woolworths Puff Pastry Sheets

Cost: $3.80

Energy: 1410kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 15.8g per 100g

Total Sugars: 1.2g per 100g

Sodium: 410mg per 100g

Frozen berries

Orchard & Vine Mixed Berries

Cost: $5.19

Packed in: Chile

Energy: 239kJ per 100g

Ingredients: strawberries (34%), blueberries (30%), blackberries (21%), raspberries (15%)

Coles Mixed Berries

Cost: $5.70

Packed in: Serbia

Energy: 171kJ per 100g

Ingredients: blueberries (37%), strawberries (33%), blackberries (15%), raspberries (15%)

Community Co Frozen Mixed Berries

Cost: $5.19

Packed in: Serbia

Energy: 159kJ per 100g

Ingredients: blackberries (35%), strawberries (25%), blueberries (20%), raspberries (20%)

Woolworths Mixed Berries

Cost: $5.70

Packed in: Chile

Energy: 171kJ per 100g

Ingredients: blueberries, strawberries, blackberries, raspberries

Cream cheese

Westacre Dairy Cream Cheese Spreadable

Cost: $2.39

Energy: 1120kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 25.6g per 100g

Total Sugars: 2.6g per 100g

Sodium: 343mg per 100g

Coles Spreadable Cream Cheese

Cost: $2.60

Energy: 1080kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 24.8g per 100g

Total Sugars: 2.6g per 100g

Sodium: 282mg per 100g

Black & Gold Cream Cheese

Cost: $2.39

Energy: 1560kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 33g per 100g

Total Sugars: 2.1g per 100g

Sodium: 234mg per 100g

Woolworths Spreadable Cream Cheese

Cost: $2.60

Energy: 1120kJ per 100g

Total Fat: 25.8g per 100g

Total Sugars: 3.9g per 100g

Sodium: 320mg per 100g

What about price?

When we survey prices for our quarterly grocery basket surveys, we shop the way you would if you were buying ingredients for a particular recipe, so if the preferred item isn’t available, we buy the next cheapest option.

That means we often end up with averaged prices that vary from the price you might find when you visit your local store. Therefore, for this article, we’ve included product prices sourced from online data gathered in early September.

On that basis, the home-brand items in this taste test cost the most at Woolworths and Coles (where prices were identical) followed by IGA and Aldi, which was cheaper than IGA by just one cent.

Our berry pastry recipe

Ingredients

6 sheets of supermarket puff pastry, thawed

2 x 250g tubs cream cheese, softened

2 cups or 500g frozen mixed berries

1 tbsp cornflour

½ tsp vanilla extract

1 tbsp lemon juice

1 tsp lemon rind

2 tbsp caster sugar

1 egg yolk, whisked

Pure icing sugar

Method

  1. Preheat oven to 200°C fan forced, with shelves placed in positions 1 and 3.
  2. Pour berries into a sieve and let thaw and drain for at least 1 hour.
  3. Once thawed and drained, place into a bowl and add 1 tbsp of the sugar and the cornflour. Allow to macerate for 30 min.
  4. Place cream cheese into a bowl, add the other tbsp of sugar, along with lemon juice, lemon rind and vanilla. Using a hand mixer, whisk until light and fluffy.
  5. Cut each pastry sheet into six rectangles and score around the edges approximately 1 cm in from the edge.
  6. Place pastry 3 cm apart onto a lined baking tray.
  7. Spread 1 tablespoon of cream cheese filling into the centre of the pastry, add 2 tbsp of berries, draining any syrup.
  8. Brush the edges with the egg yolk.
  9. Bake in the oven for 20 minutes or until the pastry is golden and the base is firm and crisp.
  10. Once removed from the oven, sieve over the icing sugar.

The post Coles, Woolworths, Aldi and IGA home brands in fruit pastry bake-off appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
762861 samples-of-each-pastry-on-trays spreading-cream-cheese-onto-puff-pastry-slices
Bone broths and stocks compared /food-and-drink/groceries/herbs-and-spices/articles/chicken-and-vegetable-stock Tue, 05 Aug 2025 14:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/chicken-and-vegetable-stock/ We compare 17 products from brands including Campbells, Maggie Beer, Matt Moran, Coles, Woolworths and Aldi.

The post Bone broths and stocks compared appeared first on Vlog.

]]>

Need to know

  • Liquid stocks can cost as little as $0.18 per 100ml all the way up to $1.18/100ml
  • Stock concentrates can be good value – you just need to add your own water
  • Bone broths are generally more expensive than stocks, but they're also less likely to contain additives

On this page:

As a desire for convenience converges with a growing interest in premium products, the range of stocks on offer at the supermarket just keeps expanding.

Once upon a time, if you didn’t want to make your own stock, your only option was stock cubes. Then came powders, liquids, concentrates and, recently, bone broths.

With more types of stocks available now than ever before, it’s hard to know if one’s better than another. We compare concentrates, liquid stocks and bone broths to see how they differ.

Text-only accessible version

We looked at liquid chicken stocks, concentrates and bone broths from the major supermarkets to see how they vary in price, nutrition and ingredients. Here is a quick snapshot of what we found.

Cheapest liquid stock: Chef’s Cupboard (Aldi) Simply Stock: $0.18/100ml
Most expensive liquid stock: Matt Moran My Perfect Chicken Stock: $1.18/100ml
Lowest sodium liquid stock: Maggie Beer Natural Chicken stock 44mg/100 ml and $0.90/100ml
Cheapest bone broth: Chef’s Cupboard (Aldi) Bone Broth Chicken $1.00/100ml
Most expensive bone broth: Maggie Beer Natural Bone Broth $1.70/100ml
Lowest sodium chicken stock concentrate: Natural Stock Co. Natural Chicken stock 211mg/100ml and $0.17/100ml
Fewest additives: Coles Slow Cooked Chicken Stock – only salt and black peppercorns. Cost is $1.00/100ml
Most additives: Woolworths Chicken Stock – includes lactic acid (270) and anticaking agent (551). Cost is $0.19/100ml
Vegetarian option: Massel Stock Chicken Style. Made with no chicken at all.

We compared 17 bone broths and stocks in liquid and concentrate form, choosing products that were available at Coles, Woolworths and Aldi in June and July 2025.

Bone broths vs stocks

In recent years, bone broths have been added to the crowded stock section of supermarkets. We’ve seen products from premium brands such as Maggie Beer; national brands such as Campbells; and supermarket brands like Aldi and Coles.

So what’s the difference between a bone broth and a stock?

Vlog home economist Fiona Mair says that while some of the ingredients can vary, it’s mainly the intended purpose that sets them apart.

Bone broths often claim to have nutritional and health benefits

“Bone broths are for heating and drinking, and they often claim to have nutritional and health benefits, which come from the collagen, gelatine, amino acids, and minerals they contain,” she says.

“On the other hand, stocks are used as a base in soups, risottos, sauces, gravies and casseroles.”

Bone broths can still be used as a stock substitute, though.

Ingredients compared

Looking at the products in our comparison – all of them found in the stock section of the supermarket – a few things stood out about the ingredients.

Both meat and bonescan beused in the production ofboth bone broths and stocks,but brothstend to more often be made from just the bones.

Additives in the bone broths are minimal and may include herbs, vegetables and apple cider vinegar (used to help extract nutrients from bones). You might also find collagen peptides and gelatin.

Both meat and bonescan beused in the production ofboth bone broths and stocks,but brothstend to more often be made from just the bones

Of the bone broths we looked at, the Aldi Chef’s Cupboard product had the most unusual ingredients, including goji berries, Chinese yam, shitake mushrooms, milk vetch root and polygonatum (also known as Solomon’s seal). In contrast, stocks are more likely to include flavour enhancers and powders, as well as ingredients such as thickeners and colours.

Some of the stocks we looked at included reconstituted stock, which means that stock concentrates were diluted with water in order to produce them. If purchasing these products, consider whether you might be better off buying stock powders or cubes and adding the water yourself.

We also found that broths are, on average, lower in sodium than stocks.

Cost comparisons

Cost is another obvious difference. Looking at the products we compared, liquid stocks were much cheaper than the bone broths.

You’ll pay on average just $0.81/100ml for the liquid stocks and concentrates in our comparison.

The bone broths we looked at cost 77% more on average: $1.44/100ml.

When comparing the price per 100ml, the cheapest product in our comparison was The Natural Stock Co Chicken Stock Concentrate. A 160g jar will set you back $10.95 but makes 6.5L, meaning it will cost just $0.17/100ml.

At the other end of the scale, Maggie Beer’s Natural Chicken Free Range Bone Broth costs $8.50 for a 500ml pouch or $1.70/100ml.

Expensive vs cheap stock

While stocks tend to be cheaper overall than bone broths, there’s still a wide range of prices.

Liquid stocks can cost as little as $0.18/100ml (Aldi’s Chef’s Cupboard Chicken Flavour Liquid Stock 1L), all the way up to $1.18/100ml (Matt Moran’s My Perfect Chicken Stock 500ml).

Also near the top of the list for price were the Coles Slow Cooked Chicken Stock ($1/100ml) and the Maggie Beer Natural Chicken Stock ($0.90/100ml).

So what’s the difference? While the Aldi stock is inexpensive, it contains additives such as maltodextrin and vegetable protein extract. In fact, four of the cheapest five stocks contain maltodextrin. In contrast, the Matt Moran product has no additives of this kind.

Fiona says when buying a stock, look for a product that contains mostly natural ingredients, such as meat bones, vegetables, herbs, water and salt.

“A good chicken stock should smell like chicken, have a balanced flavour and not be too salty,” she says. “It should have a smooth, slightly silky mouthfeel and should be clear, not cloudy. A natural golden colour is also a sign of quality.”

The products in our comparison

Liquid stocks

Chef’s Cupboard Simply Stock, Chicken Flavour 1L (Aldi)

Coles Real Chicken Stock 1L

Woolworths Chicken Stock 1L

Unox Liquid Stock, Real Chicken 1L

Massel Stock, Chicken Style 1L

Campbells Real Stock Chicken 1L

Maggie Beer Natural Chicken Stock 1L

Coles Slow Cooked Chicken Stock 500ml

Matt Moran My Perfect Chicken Stock 500ml

Stock concentrates

Continental Stock Pot Sensations, Chicken 112g

Vegeta Chicken Stock Pot 112g

The Natural Stock Co Chicken Stock Concentrate 160g

Bone broths

Campbells Bone Broth 500ml (screw top bottle)

Campbells Real Bone Broth 500ml (pouch)

Coles Chicken Bone Broth 500ml

Maggie Beer Natural Bone Broth 500ml

Chef’s Cupboard Chicken Bone Broth 500ml (Aldi)

Are concentrated stocks any good?

With many of the liquid stocks in our comparison you’re essentially paying for (and carrying home) a lot of water. So why not buy a concentrate? They tend to be cheaper, too.

The Continental Stock Pot Sensations works out to be just $0.23 per 100ml, the Natural Stock Company product costs $0.17/100ml, and the Vegeta Chicken Stock Pots are $0.20/100ml.

“With a concentrated stock, you have control of how much you want to make or add to your recipe,” says Fiona.

“It is much more economical in the long run, has less packaging and reduces the weight in your shopping bag. They’ll also take up less space in your pantry or fridge.”

Sodium and additives in broths and stocks

The bone broths we looked at tended to have fewer additives than the stocks and concentrates, and most seemed to align with broth’s reputation as a ‘wellness’ product.

On the other hand, the stocks we compared contained a wide range of sweeteners, sugars, flavour enhancers, thickeners and texture agents, stabilisers and preservatives. Some contained added fats and oils, and dehydrated and powdered ingredients were also present.

While none of these are inherently bad, if you’re trying to avoid too many additives or processed ingredients, be careful when buying these products.

Sodium is another big differentiator. Liquid stocks have approximately 48% more sodium on average than bone broths (298mg versus 182mg).

However, sodium can vary widely in the liquid stocks we compared: The Campbell’s Real Chicken stock contained 447mg per 100ml, while Maggie Beer’s Natural Chicken Stock was lowest in sodium, just 44mg per 100ml.

Making your own stock

While convenience is an important consideration for many of us, Fiona says it’s very simple to make your own chicken stock. You don’t even need to strictly follow a recipe.

“Keep a plastic bag in the freezer to add any vegetable peels or leftover bones from dinner. When you’re ready to make a stock, add them to the pot,” she says.

If you’d prefer a bit more guidance, Fiona’s recipe below is an easy one to start with.

Fiona's chicken stock recipe

Fiona’s chicken stock recipe

Ingredients

  • 1kg chicken wings
  • 3 litres water
  • 1 tablespoon salt

Method

  • Place ingredients in a large 4-litre saucepan.
  • Bring to the boil, then reduce heat and simmer for roughly 2–4 hours (the longer the better).
  • Strain the stock using a fine sieve, and discard the chicken wings.
  • Stock can be used immediately or poured into containers and frozen for later.

Tips

  • If using stock straight away, let it sit for a few minutes to allow the fat to come to the top, which you can then spoon off.
  • If using stock from frozen, scrape off and discard the layer of fat that will be sitting on top. This can be done before defrosting.

Broths and stocks comparison tables

Text-only accessible version

Chicken stock (liquid)

Chef’s Cupboard Simply Stock Real Chicken Flavour 1L

Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.18

Sodium (mg/100mL): 352
Packaging: Carton

Coles Real Chicken Stock
Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.19
Sodium (mg/100mL): 334
Packaging: Carton

Woolworths Chicken Stock
Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.19
Sodium (mg/100mL): 390
Packaging: Carton

Unox Real Chicken Stock
Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.30
Sodium (mg/100mL): 265
Packaging: Carton

Massel Chicken Style Stock
Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.42
Sodium (mg/100mL): 330
Packaging: Carton

Campbell’s Real Stock Chicken

Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.45

Sodium (mg/100mL): 447

Packaging: Carton

Maggie Beer Natural Chicken Stock
Cost per 100ml* ($): 0.90
Sodium (mg/100mL): 44
Packaging: Pouch


Coles Slow Cooked Chicken Stock
Cost per 100ml* ($): 1.00
Sodium (mg/100mL): 148
Packaging: Pouch

Matt Moran My Perfect Chicken Stock
Cost per 100ml* ($): 1.18
Sodium (mg/100mL): 153
Packaging: Pouch

Chicken Stock (Concentrate)

The Natural Stock Co. Chicken Stock Concentrate

Cost per 100ml* ($): 0.17
Sodium (mg/100mL): 211

Vegeta Chicken Stock Pot

Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.20

Sodium (mg/100mL): 432

Continental Stock Pot Sensations Chicken

Cost per 100mL* ($): 0.23

Sodium (mg/100mL): 475

Chicken Bone Broths

Chef’s Cupboard Bone Broth

Cost per 100mL* ($): 1.00

Sodium (mg/100mL): 220

Coles Chicken Bone Broth

Cost per 100mL* ($): 1.26

Sodium (mg/100mL): 120

Campbell’s Bone Broth

Cost per 100mL* ($): 1.40

Sodium (mg/100mL): 111

Campbell’s Real Bone Broth

Cost per 100mL* ($): 1.60

Sodium (mg/100mL): 112

Maggie Beer Natural Bone Broth

Cost per 100mL* ($): 1.70

Sodium (mg/100mL): 99

The post Bone broths and stocks compared appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
760391
How to make the best pumpkin soup /food-and-drink/groceries/fruit-and-vegetables/articles/how-to-make-the-best-pumpkin-soup Tue, 24 Jun 2025 14:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/how-to-make-the-best-pumpkin-soup/ We made soup with ingredients from Woolies, Coles, IGA and Aldi. Vlog taste-testers picked the yummiest one.

The post How to make the best pumpkin soup appeared first on Vlog.

]]>

Need to know

  • Even with the same ingredients and methodology, you can get very different results
  • Price is not necessarily an indicator of quality when it comes to your soup ingredients
  • The right produce is key, so choose carefully

For more than a year, we’ve been comparing the prices of different items at the four major supermarkets. While we’ve strived to match the products in our basket so that they have similar ingredients, countries of origin and pack size, there are inevitably small variations, and this can affect the perceived quality.

While the focus of our quarterly basket survey is on price, we also recognise that quality is important – if something costs less but is of poor quality, you may not feel that you’ve got value for money.

Our results showed the huge variation that different products and fresh produce can have on the outcome of your cooking

It’s also true, as we know from our decades of product testing, that paying more doesn’t necessarily mean you get a better product, so figuring out which products are best is not as simple as paying more to get better quality.

To evaluate the quality of ingredients purchased across the four major supermarkets, we bought the essentials required to make a winter classic – pumpkin soup. All of the ingredients were featured in ourmost recent grocery basket comparison.

Vlog home economist Fiona Mair cooked up four separate batches using the same recipe (shared below), and lucky Vlog staff blind taste-tested the finished dishes.

Our results showed the huge variation that different products and fresh produce can have on the outcome of your cooking.

Text-only accessible version

Which supermarket’s ingredients make the best pumpkin soup?

We purchased ingredients from each of the major supermarkets and prepared soup following the same recipe for each batch. We then conducted a blind taste test of each version to find out which won on flavour.

Woolworths: Pumpkin + onion + stock = $7.84 1st place

Aldi: Pumpkin + onion + stock = $6.20 2nd place

IGA: Pumpkin + onion + stock = $10.86 3rd place

Coles: Pumpkin + onion + stock = $7.91 4th place

Which pumpkin soup was superior?

Our tasters told us that the pumpkin soup prepared using the Woolworths’ ingredients was the best of the bunch, followed closely by Aldi’s.

The soups made from IGA and Coles ingredients were a more distant third and fourth.

Many commented on how much each sample differed, despite the same recipe being used to prepare each batch

Many taste-testers commented on how much each sample differed, despite the same recipe being used to prepare each batch. Which just goes to show how much impact your ingredients will have on the result.

In terms of price, the pumpkin, stock and onion from Woolworths cost $7.84, and at Coles the price was $7.91. The same products cost $6.20 from Aldi and $10.86 from IGA. These calculations are based on the price of 1.5kg of pumpkin and the full litre of stock.

Fiona’s pumpkin soup recipe

Ingredients

  • 1.5kg butternut pumpkin, peeled and cut into 5cm chunks
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 1 brown onion, peeled and diced sliced thinly
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 500 to 700ml vegetable stock (adjust according to the desired thickness of the soup)
  • 1 tsp salt
  • ½ tsp black pepper

Preparation method

  1. Preheat oven to 200°C fan-forced.
  2. Place the pumpkin pieces into a baking tray with the olive oil. Rub the oil over the pumpkin pieces.
  3. Bake in oven until pumpkin is soft and dark golden brown (approximately 20 min).
  4. On a medium heat, melt the butter in the saucepan and fry onion until soft (approximately 4 min).
  5. Add the roasted pumpkin, stock, salt and pepper.
  6. Bring to the boil, reduce the heat and simmer for 15 min with the lid on.
  7. Remove from the heat and allow to cool slightly. Then, using a stick blender, blend the soup until smooth and silky.
We bought the essentials required to make pumpkin soup from the four major supermarkets, and conducted a blind taste-test of the finished dishes to find out which tasted best.

How do the ingredients compare?

While price is one way to look at the products in question, it’s not the only factor that influences purchasing decisions.

For nearly everyone, the quality of the items we buy is also important.

Vegetable stocks

The vegetable stocks from Coles and Woolworths were very similar, with closely matched ingredients and nutritional values. The ingredient lists were almost identical, the sodium levels were just 2mg different, and carbohydrates were essentially the same – just 0.1g different.

The Aldi and Campbell’s (from IGA) vegetable stocks were also very similar to each other, with similar ingredients, sodium levels and carbohydrates.

Stock ingredients compared

Woolworths Vegetable Stock

Ingredients: Reconstituted vegetable stock (97%): (water, onion, carrot, celery, tomato, leek, garlic, parsley, black peppercorns, bay leaf, salt), yeast extract, maltodextrin, salt, onion powder, garlic powder, sugar, natural flavour, caramelised sugar syrup, sunflower oil, spice, acacia gum.

Energy/100ml: 27kJ

Sodium/100ml: 302mg

Carbohydrate/100g: 1.4g

Sugars/100g: <1.0g

Coles Real Vegetable Stock

Ingredients: Reconstituted vegetable stock (97%): (water, onion, carrot, celery, tomato, leek, garlic, parsley, pepper, bayleaf, salt, yeast extract), maltodextrin, salt, vegetable powders (onion, garlic), sugar, natural flavours, yeast extract, caramelised sugar syrup, sunflower oil, spice.

Energy/100ml: 33kJ

Sodium/100ml: 300mg

Carbohydrate/100g: 1.5g

Sugars/100g: <1.0g

Chef’s Cupboard Simply Stock Vegetable (Aldi)

Ingredients: Vegetable stock (96%): (Water, carrots, celery, cabbage, garlic, onions, bay leaves, parsley, thyme), sugar, salt, glucose, yeast extract.

Energy/100ml: 34kJ

Sodium/100ml: 539mg

Carbohydrate/100g: 1.9g

Sugars/100g: 1.9g

Campbell’s Real Stock Vegetable (IGA)

Ingredients: Vegetable stock (97%): (Water, carrots, celery, cabbage, garlic, onions, bay leaves, parsley, thyme), sugar, salt, glucose.

Energy/100ml: 34kJ

Sodium/100ml: 542mg

Carbohydrate/100g: 1.9g

Sugars/100g: 1.8g

The vegetable stocks from Coles and Woolies had similar ingredients and nutritional values; while the Aldi and Campbell’s products were similar to each other.

Choosing the right produce

Pumpkin

It might seem obvious, but a good pumpkin is key to producing a good pumpkin soup. An underripe pumpkin may have played a part in the poor showing of the soup prepared from Coles’ ingredients.

“Pumpkins can be underripe, and a butternut pumpkin that’s harvested too early will have a higher moisture content and a less developed flavour compared to a fully ripe one,” says Fiona.

A butternut pumpkin that’s harvested too early will have a higher moisture content and a less developed flavour

When choosing your pumpkin, look for one with a firm, dry stem that feels heavy for its size. The skin should be a deep beige colour and should sound hollow when you tap on it.

“The Coles pumpkin was light compared to the other supermarket pumpkins and seemed to be underripe, which meant the flavour was limited,” she says.

Onion

The other variable in our taste test was the onion.

While preparing the soups, Fiona saw a noticeable difference in the caramelisation achieved, with the onion from Woolworths browning and caramelising more quickly.

She also noticed that the Woolworths onion had drier, darker roots than those bought at the other stores, indicating it could have been older than the others.

As onions age, the process of converting starch to sugar occurs, making them sweeter

“Older onions tend to have higher sugar content and will caramelise faster. As onions age, the process of converting starch to sugar occurs, making them sweeter,” says Fiona.

“This was noticeable in the initial cooking of the onions in the butter and contributed to the sweetness of the soup.”

Fiona’s tips for an exceptional soup

For Fiona, the quality of the produce is the key to cooking success.

“Good-quality vegetables will produce an overall better flavour,” she says. “Don’t settle for less. After all, you are putting your time, energy and money into making a meal for yourself, your family or your friends.”

She also suggests that you may not even need to use vegetable stocks.

“When making a vegetable soup – whether it is a pumpkin, potato and leek, or minestrone – consider replacing the vegetable stock with water and include extra vegetables instead,” Fiona advises.

“Flavours such as garlic can be added, but should be used sparingly as they can be overpowering,” she adds.

Some pre-packaged vegetable stocks could possibly ruin your dish with overpowering dried seasonings and excess salt

Fiona Mair, Vlog home economist

Fiona also recommends you add carrots for sweetness and fresh herbs, rather than dried, for a fresher flavour.

“An extra onion will also add flavour and sweetness when softened and caramelised first,” she says.

Fiona also notes that another benefit of omitting the store-bought stock is that you control the amount of salt that you add and therefore the amount of sodium in your food.

“Some pre-packaged vegetable stocks could possibly ruin your dish with overpowering dried seasonings and excess salt,” she warns.

The post How to make the best pumpkin soup appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
763550 soup-taste-test-voting each-stock-in-a-glass-with-the-supermarket-stock-carton-behind
The supermarket home-brand cookies that taste better than Arnott’s /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/arnotts-vs-home-brand-choc-chip-cookies Sun, 27 Oct 2024 13:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/arnotts-vs-home-brand-choc-chip-cookies/ We pitted Australia's best known brand against cheaper supermarket bikkies – the results were surprising.

The post The supermarket home-brand cookies that taste better than Arnott’s appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
A little treat is often the thing that gets us through the day, and a chocolate chip cookie can be just the ticket to make that afternoon slump a little more bearable.

If your much-anticipated treat turns out to be a fizzer, it can really put a dampener on your day – after all, what’s the point of an indulgence if it’s a disappointment?

That’s why we tend to stick to our favourite brands and products – we know exactly what to expect when we open the pack, and we know it’ll hit the spot every time.

After years of successful biscuit-making, you’d assume that Arnott’s has choc chip cookies nailed, but how do they actually stack up?

Arnott’s is one of those tried and trusted brands: it’s been around since the 1800s and is responsible for many iconic favourites such as Tim Tams and Iced Vovos.

After years of successful biscuit-making, you’d assume that Arnott’s has choc chip cookies nailed, but how do they actually stack up against other brands?

Surprisingly, not as well as you might think.

Prepare to have your cookie-craving mind blown: you don’t have to stick to the well-known brands to get your fix of perfectly crunchy, biscuit-y bliss. You can actually pay less for a tastier treat.

(That means you can eat more of them, right?)

We’ll tell you which cookies to put in your biscuit jar, and which to leave on the shelf.

Cookies were stripped of their branding and blind taste tested.

How we found the best choc chip cookies

We set three experts the difficult task of blind tasting 22 different choc chip cookies (tough gig, we know).

They didn’t know which was which, so couldn’t be swayed by branding or packaging.

They judged each cookie on its own merits, assessing things like flavour, texture, aroma and appearance, giving a score for each aspect.

Each cookie’s Health Star Rating was converted into a percentage; this then made up 10% of each cookie’s overall score. (Although we know people don’t exactly eat cookies for their health!)

The results of our taste test might surprise you – and perhaps change your shopping habits.

Are Arnott’s chocolate chip cookies the best?

According to our expert judges, no.

In a shock turn of events, the well-known biscuit brand didn’t even make the top three, being ousted by – shock horror – supermarket home-brand cookies.

Turns out you don’t need to buy based on brand to get the best bikkie.

So how did the Arnott’s cookies score?Not as well as you might expect.

Text-only accessible version

Arnott’s vs home-brand cookies

Which takes the biscuit?

Coles Ultimate Cookies: 84% (Vlog expert taste test score)

Aldi Belmont Signature Cookies: 81%

Aldi Belmont Cookies Choc Chip: 80%

Arnott’s Australia’s Premier Choc Chip Cookies: 78%

Top-tier taste at a budget price: Coles Ultimate Cookies.

The budget bikkies that beat Arnott’s

If taste is everything (and let’s be honest, it is for most of us when it comes to treats), then one unassuming supermarket cookie takes the biscuit: Coles Ultimate Cookies 40% Chocolate Chip.

Coles’ cookies scored 84% in our taste test, and only narrowly missed out on the top spot overall because of their low Health Star Rating of 0.5. (The cookies that took out the top spot have a 1.5 Health Star Rating).

While your doctor might not be a fan of these, your tastebuds definitely will be. And at 19 cents a cookie (compared to 24 cents a pop for Arnott’s), your budget will be happy too.

Plus, they’re made from real dark chocolate chips – unlike Arnott’s and most other brands that use compound chocolate, which is made with vegetable fats instead of cocoa fats/solids.

These Aldi cookies are another supermarket biscuit that out-scored Arnott’s.

Want more bikkie for your budget?

To get the best cookie for your coin, head to Aldi for its Belmont Signature Cookies.

They beat Arnott’s in our taste test and will cost you just 22 cents a cookie, or $1 per 100g – the cheapest unit price (per 100g) of all the top scorers.

Like the Arnott’s and Coles cookies, they also contain 40% choc chips, but knowing that you’re getting the same chocolate hit for less might make them taste even better.

These Coles bakery cookies are perfect for when you want to splurge on a treat.

The luxe options

If you really want to treat yourself, you need to get out of that packaged biscuit aisle and over to the bakery, stat!

Two of our judges’ favourite cookies overall are baked in-house at Coles and Woolies. They took out first and third place in our taste test. You’ll notice they cost a lot more per cookie than some of the options above, but they’re also significantly bigger – their price per 100g is only slightly higher than the Arnott’s cookies (Coles $1.83, Woolworths $1.77 vs Arnotts $1.61).

First place: Coles Dreams Crumb True New York Choc Chip Cookies

  • Vlog score: 78% (Recommended)
  • Price: $5.20/pack; $1.30/cookie

Third place: Woolworths Chocolate Chunk Cookies

  • Vlog score: 75% (Recommended)
  • Price: $5.50/pack; $1.10/cookie

The post The supermarket home-brand cookies that taste better than Arnott’s appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
759257 choc-chip-cookies-taste-test-plate coles-ultimate-cookies-40-chocolate-chip aldi-belmont-signature-cookies-40-chocolate-chip coles-bakery-dreams-crumb-true-new-york-choc-chip-cookies
What is the best chocolate chip cookie? /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/buying-guides/chocolate-chip-cookies Sun, 29 Sep 2024 14:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/chocolate-chip-cookies/ We review chocolate chip cookies from Coles, Woolworths, Aldi, Cadbury, Arnott's and more.

The post What is the best chocolate chip cookie? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
Chocolate chip cookies are hands-down the best thing to dunk in a warm glass of milk. Personally, I think the best cookie is chewy in the middle, with a crunchy exterior.

On this page:

But we all have our personal preferences. We asked the Vlog community how they prefer their cookies – chewy, crunchy or a bit of both.

“Crunchy” and “a bit of both” tied for first place, each with 36% of the votes, followed by chewy with 18%. Many people are loyal to a particular brand; in this guide, we tested 22 different chocolate chip cookies, sourced from the major supermarkets and some popular online retailers, to find out which is the best.

The best tasting chocolate chip cookies

Out of the 22 chocolate chip cookies we reviewed, the top three scorers were not the premium cookies we expected to score highly.

Coles takes the biscuit in this test, with two of its own-brand choc chip cookies coming into the top three, followed closely by Woolworths’ (baked instore) chocolate chunk cookies.

This Coles bakery cookie took out the top spot in our test.

1. Coles Bakery Dreams Crumb True New York Choc Chip Cookies

Vlog Expert Rating: 78%

Sensory score: 83%

Sugars: 19.2g per 100g

Chocolate chips: 30%

Price: $1.83 per 100g

Experts say: “Big round and rustic with lots of dark chocolate chunks. Quite crunchy with a little bit of a chew in the centre. Nice semi-sweet chocolate lifts an otherwise average cookie.”

“Cookie was baked well with a subtle vanilla aroma. The texture was a little dry. The chocolate chunks were of good size and added a strong flavour.”

“Chocolate not evenly dispersed as there are some very large chunks and some very small pieces. The large chunks are in the middle of the cookie.”

This own-brand cookie from Coles surprised our judges.

2. Coles Ultimate Cookies 40% Chocolate Chip

Vlog Expert Rating: 77%

Sensory score: 84%

Sugars: 36g per 100g

Chocolate chips: 40%

Price: $1.25 per 100g

Experts say:“Great rustic cookie with plenty of choc chips. Light crisp texture, which was a little chewy. Plenty of choc chips with great flavour.”

“Slightly rustic appearance, nice thickness, lots of chocolate chips. Nice soft crunch. Lots of dark chocolate. Not too sweet, nice biscuit.” “Uniform, visually appealing cookie. Unfortunately it has poor mouthfeel due to fat lining the palate.”

A Woolworths own-brand cookie also made the top three.

3. Woolworths Bakery Chocolate Chunk Cookie (baked instore)

Vlog Expert Rating: 75%

Sensory score: 82%

Sugars: 35g per 100g

Chocolate chips: 32%

Price: $1.77 per 100g

Experts say:“Uneven chocolate, some large pieces and some very small, good bake with a little dry crumb.”

“Big dark chocolate chunks, looks rustic and inviting. Chocolate and butterscotch aromas. Not overly sweet, soft cookie, nice flavour.”

“Great rustic looking cookie with a lovely golden colour, baked well, with a nice texture when broken. Large chocolate chunks distributed throughout with a great flavour.”

The top performers had higher than average chocolate chip percentages and the top two scorers used real dark chocolate chunks instead of compound chocolate.

Compound chocolate is chocolate’s lower quality, cheaper cousin – it uses vegetable fats in place of cocoa fats/solids.

The tastiest choc chip cookie, which received a sensory score of 84%, was the Coles Ultimate Cookies 40% Chocolate Chip, which outperformed the bakery-style cookies in the test. The judges described it as a great, rustic-looking cookie with plenty of chocolate chips.

The healthiest chocolate chip cookies

Most of us accept that when we grab a choc chip cookie, we’re going to be getting a fair whack of kilojoules, sugars, saturated fats, and potentially trans fats.

But if there is a choc chip cookie that tastes great and is on the healthier side of what you could expect for a snack like this, then why wouldn’t you go for it? Well, the good news is that the Coles Bakery Dreams Crumb True New York Choc Chip Cookies had the highest Health Star Rating of the cookies we tested, and also had a very good sensory score of 83%.

Part of the reason why the Health Star Rating was so high for this cookie was that the sugars per 100 grams were much lower than for the other cookies we looked at – 19.2 grams per 100 grams, compared to the average for this category of 36 grams per 100 grams. Watch out though, this cookie, along with most cookies in this test, contains palm oil.

The use of palm oil in processed and fast foods has raised a number of environmental concerns, particularly around deforestation. There is no obligation to label the presence of palm oil in foods, so be aware that unspecified vegetable oil/fat may actually be palm oil.

Trans fats in cookies

Trans fats (also called trans fatty acids) are vegetable oils that have been treated through a process called hydrogenation. These fats clog the arteries and can increase the risk of heart attacks and death. Every year, more than 278,000 deaths globally per annum are linked to the intake of man-made trans fats from food.

Manufacturers don’t have to list the amount of trans fats in their products unless the label contains a nutrition or health claim about its benefits for cholesterol levels or heart health, or the levels of saturated or non-saturated fatty acids present.

Every year, more than 278,000 deaths globally per annum are linked to the intake of man-made trans fats from food

Four products in our test specifically state that they contain 0.1 grams of trans fats or less per 100 grams – these are the Paradise Cottage Cookies Choc Chip Indulgence, Coles (Bakery) Choc Chip Cookies, Woolworths The King of Chunky Choc Chip Cookies 40%, and Coles (Bakery) Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie 40% Chocolate Chip.

Anything over two grams of trans fats per 100 grams is considered high.

Be careful of the Woolworths (Bakery) Choc Chip Cookies, as they contain hydrogenated vegetable fat and the label doesn’t disclose how much is in the product. As noted above, hydrogenation is a process used to produce trans fats.

Each cookie was numbered so our testers could record their impressions without knowing which cookie they were tasting.

How we tested chocolate chip cookies

Products

We tested 22 choc chip or choc chunk cookie products available in major national supermarket chains, including Coles, Woolworths, IGA and Aldi. We also included popular cookies found nationally on online retailers. We did not include bite-sized, triple choc or gluten-free cookies. The price per 100g is based on the pack price in Sydney stores (not on special) in July 2024.

Tasting

Our panel of three experts tasted the choc chip cookie samples ‘blind’ (without knowing the brands) at room temperature, and independently judged each sample on appearance, aroma, flavour and texture.

Scores

The Vlog Expert Rating, our overall score, consists of 90% sensory and 10% nutrition (based entirely on the Health Star Rating).

The sensory weightings are comprised of:

  • flavour (50%)
  • texture (30%)
  • appearance (10%)
  • aroma (10%).

We recommend choc chip cookies with a Vlog Expert Rating of 75% or more.

Meet our expert taste testers

Ian Huntleyis a pastry chef by trade and has been in the industry for 35 years. He studied confectionery, cake decorating and bread making in the UK before moving to Australia in the mid-1980s. After five years of working in two of Sydney’s top hotels, the InterContinental and the Regent, he started his wholesale patisserie business, supplying desserts and pastries to airlines, department stores, hospitals, restaurants and coffee shops. Today Ian is the chair of judges for the Royal Agricultural Society (RAS) Professional Bakery competition and chief assessor for patisserie for leading French culinary school Le Cordon Bleu.

Jane Bardellmight fill her days checking facts and figures as one of our esteemed Vlog verifiers, but she spends her weekends and evenings perfecting her brioche, refining her frangipane tarts and decorating cakes for special occasions. She’s just as comfortable manipulating data in a spreadsheet as she is shaping a loaf of sourdough. She’s completed training in fine food sensory analysis, and is even a multi-award-winning pastry chef – if you count the prestigious annual Vlog staff lemon bake-off.

Michele Walshhas worked in the baking industry for more than 30 years, starting as an apprentice and now working as a tertiary-educated professional in the vocational education and training sector, where she delivers training to apprentices and non-apprentices in retail baking and patisserie. She has more than 15 years’ experience in judging, including the RAS Professional Bakery and WorldSkills trades competitions.

Makes approximately 17 cookies

Ingredients

2 eggs

½ cup brown sugar

½ cup caster sugar

1 tsp vanilla

¼ tsp salt

½ cup vegetable oil

1 cup plain flour

¾ cup self-rising flour

½ tsp bicarbonate soda

200g dark chocolate chips

Method

1. Using a whisk or hand mixer, beat eggs, sugar, vanilla and salt in a bowl until mixture lightens and becomes thickened.

2. Add oil, flours, bicarbonate of soda and chocolate chips. Mix well.

3. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 1 hour.

4. Once the dough is firm, roll into two-tablespoon portions, flatten slightly and place on a tray lined with baking paper. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 15 minutes.

5. The cookie dough can be frozen; place into an airtight container and keep in the freezer until needed. Otherwise, continue with the cooking instructions below.

Cooking instructions

1. Preheat the oven at 180°C.

2. Line a baking tray with a sheet of baking paper, place up to 10 cookies onto the paper and allow for the cookies to spread. Bake for 12–15 mins.

3. Allow to cool for 2 mins on the tray, then transfer to a cooling rack, or serve warm with ice cream.

Tips

  • Don’t crowd the tray, leave approx. 2 cm space between each cookie.
  • For a healthier cookie, try one of these two variations:
    • Add ½ cup oats or raisins and reduce the self-rising flour by a ¼ cup
    • Use ½ whole meal flour ½ white

The cost for each cookie from this recipe is about 47 cents per cookie, which is much more affordable than the bakery-style cookies in this test with an average of 99 cents per cookie.

The post What is the best chocolate chip cookie? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
769763 coles-dreams-crumb-true-new-york-choc-chip-cookies coles-ultimate-40-per-cent-chocolate-chip-cookies woolworths-bakery-chocolate-chunk-cookies 187329-Choc-Chip-Cookies-Trays-3_cropped
How do supermarket own-brand frozen chips stack up? /food-and-drink/groceries/snack-foods/articles/best-supermarket-frozen-chips Wed, 29 May 2024 14:00:00 +0000 /uncategorized/post/best-supermarket-frozen-chips/ They’re cheap as chips, but these options from Aldi, Coles, Woolies and IGA may not be worth your oven space.

The post How do supermarket own-brand frozen chips stack up? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
A freezer staple and quick dinner winner loved by young and old, frozen chips are a common addition to our grocery baskets. Adding crispness, crunch and a side of deliciousness to burgers, sausages, steaks or fish fillets, they’re a relatively cheap and convenient option to bulk out meals.

In our latest act of national service (you’re welcome), the Vlog team fired up the air fryers and taste-tested 34 different brands of frozen chips to find out which are the best, based on flavour, texture, aroma, appearance and nutrition.

The winner in the straight-cut category was Birds Eye Golden Crunch Thin and Crispy Chips with a score of 88% ($5.80 for 900g; $0.64 per 100g), but they were at the pricier end of the products we reviewed.

We also tested cheaper own-brand offerings from Aldi, Coles, Woolies and IGA which may appeal if you’re cutting your chip budget. So how did they perform?

Home-brand frozen chips, ranked

While we often find in Vlog testing that cheaper home-brand products outperform their pricier branded counterparts, sadly this isn’t really the case on the frozen chip front – none of these own-brand straight-cut chips scored higher than 67%, so even if the price is right you may want to think twice before chucking them in your trolley.

But if you’re dedicated to cutting costs by shopping own-brand, these are how the straight-cut options we looked at from each major supermarket stacked up.

1. Aldi Seasons Pride Super Crunch Chips (Vlog score: 67%)

Of all the basic straight-cut supermarket own-brand chips we tested, this budget buy from Aldi scored the highest at 67%, and it’s also one of the cheapest products at 40 cents per 100g (that’s a tick for your grocery budget!)

But, although these chips scored higher on taste than other supermarket buys, they were scored slightly down on nutrition. A quick look at the back of the packet shows there are lots of ingredients besides potato that have been added, including salt, sugars and thickener, so keep this in mind if you like to avoid additives.

Read the full review of Aldi Seasons Pride Super Crunch Chips.

2. Woolworths Essentials French Fries (Vlog score: 66%)

While technically a skinny chip, these Woolies French Fries are a notable inclusion here as Woolworths doesn’t have am own-brand standard straight-cut chip (their Woolworths Australian Beer Batter Steakhouse Chips were ranked the best in our beer-battered chip category however).

These fries score 66% and cost the same as the Aldi chips at 40 cents per 100g. Consisting of just two ingredients – 96% potato and 4% sunflower oil (without any of the additives we found in many products, including our Birds Eye winner) – this product received a nutrition score of 90% and a taste test score of 64%.

Comments from our taste testers included: “Nice structure, tastes of potato, good crispness”. While another said :”Somewhat crispy on the outside and soft in the middle”.

Read the full review of Woolworths Essentials French Fries.

3. Coles Classic Straight-Cut Chips (Vlog score: 60%)

Next-best chip off the block is from Coles, costing the same as the Woolies fries and with the same two ingredients (just 97% potato and 3% sunflower oil), but with a score of 60%.

These chips also received the same nutrition score as the Woolies fries (90%) and have lower than average sodium with 80mg per 100g serve (the average sodium content of the chips we tested was 118mg per 100 grams).

But Coles’ offering was outclassed by the Woolworths option due to taste. Our taste testers weren’t huge fans, describing the flavour of these chips as “mediocre” with “not much of an aroma”.

Read the full review of Coles Classic Straight-Cut Chips.

4. Black & Gold Straight Cut Potato Chips (Vlog score: 59%)

Neck and neck with the Coles chips above, these IGA own-brand chips are ever so slightly more expensive than the Coles and Woolies options (40.5 cents per 100g), and scored 59% overall.

Although they have less sodium than the Coles and Woolies chips at 29mg per 100g, a quick perusal of the ingredients list shows they have added dextrose which is a type of sugar added to frozen chip products to help make them crunchy and stay crisp for longer.

Unfortunately, the dextrose doesn’t even seem to be doing a good job – one of our taste testers noted that they didn’t crisp up when cooked and had “limited flavour”.

Read the full review of Black & Gold Straight Cut Potato Chips.

The post How do supermarket own-brand frozen chips stack up? appeared first on Vlog.

]]>
759786 aldi-seasons-pride-super-crunch-chips_1 woolworths-essentials-french-fries_1 coles-classic-straight-cut-chips_1 black-gold-straight-cut-potato-chips_1